Updated
Cables: handy but weak
Cables are light and flexible, but most can be cut in seconds with bolt cutters. They work as a second lock for a wheel, not as main protection.
Combination cables are even more vulnerable: codes can often be felt out by working the dials. Avoid them for a valuable bike left for long periods.
U-locks and chains
A hardened steel U-lock offers the best security-to-weight ratio for the city. Pick one small enough to limit room for a pry bar, and lock the frame to a solid rack.
A thick hardened steel chain with a good padlock is very strong but heavy. Folding locks are a good compromise, easy to carry on the frame.
Lost key or jammed lock
A locksmith can often open a bike lock without destroying the bike: picking for simple models, decoding for combination locks, or controlled cutting as a last resort.
As with a car or home, we check that the bike is yours before opening: a receipt, a photo of you with the bike or the registered serial number helps a lot.
Locking your bike properly
The best lock is useless if it's used badly. Always lock the frame, not just the wheel, to a solid rack anchored to the ground. Avoid posts that are too short, chain-link fences and young trees a thief can slip around or cut. Place the U-lock high on the frame, away from the ground, where it's harder to brace a tool against the pavement.
Fill the space inside the U with the frame, the wheel and the rack: the less space left, the harder it is to slip in a lever. Also turn the keyhole downward, out of the rain. In winter, that simple habit limits frozen cylinders, one of the most common reasons we get called for a jammed bike lock.
In the spring, also check your lock before taking the bike out again: a cylinder that spent the winter outside can be seized by rust or salt. A few drops of dry lubricant and a few turns of the key are often enough. If it still resists, it's better to have it checked or replaced than to end up stuck with a bike locked in front of the office at the end of the day.
Combination and smart locks
Combination locks mean no key to lose, but entry-level models can be decoded by manipulating the dials. If you choose one, go for a sturdy model from a good brand with at least four or five dials, and change the default combination as soon as you buy it.
Smart locks open with an app or a fingerprint. They're convenient, but they depend on a battery and on your phone. Choose one with a backup option, like a code or a key, and check its mechanical strength: electronics don't make up for a thin shackle that a pair of cutters can go through.
How much to spend on a lock
The more the bike is worth, the stronger the lock should be, especially for an e-bike worth several thousand dollars. A good hardened-steel U-lock costs more than a cable, but it's still far cheaper than replacing the bike and everything attached to it, from lights to racks and bags.
Think about the keys too: write down the key number supplied with the lock and keep the spare somewhere other than on your key ring. If you lose everything, a locksmith can often open the lock, but a very tough model may require cutting, which leaves it unusable, so a spare key is always the cheaper option.
Good habits
Note your bike's serial number (under the bottom bracket) and keep a photo. Many U-lock makers provide a card with the key number to order a spare: keep it at home.
Use two different lock types: a U-lock for the frame and rear wheel, a cable for the front wheel. A thief equipped for one is rarely equipped for the other.
Frequently asked questions
Can a locksmith open my bike lock?
Often yes, after confirming the bike is yours.
What's the best lock type for the city?
A hardened steel U-lock, ideally combined with a cable for the front wheel.
Can a U-lock key be remade?
Yes with the maker's key card; otherwise we replace the lock.
